Estimated reading time: 11 minutes
The age-old debate of Upper East Side vs Upper West Side has puzzled many looking for their perfect Manhattan home. These two legendary neighborhoods, separated by Central Park, each have their distinct personality and charm.
Both are some of the most expensive neighborhoods in NYC, with beautiful pre-war buildings and tree-lined streets. So, choosing between the Upper East Side and Upper West Side comes down to the vibe you’re after.
Before you start apartment hunting, let’s break down what makes each side tick—and help you figure out which one feels more like home.
Upper East Side or Upper West Side: Table of Contents
- Overview of Upper East Side vs. Upper West Side
- What is Living on the Upper East Side Like?
- What is Living on the Upper West Side Like?
- Is the Upper East Side or Upper West Side More Expensive?
- Rental Game: What You Need to Know
- Public Transportation and Commuting: UES vs. UWS
- Nightlife, Dining, and Lifestyle: UES vs. UWS
Enjoy a Hassle-Free, High End Rental Experience in NYC for Stays of 1 Month or Longer.
Fully-furnished New York rooms and apartments with flexible lease. Apply today and move in tomorrow.
Overview of Upper East Side vs. Upper West Side
Geographic Location and General Feel
Upper East Side: The Upper East Side feels like stepping into an episode of Gossip Girl. Think pristine townhouses and designer boutiques. Madison and Park Avenues cut through the neighborhood, and even the sidewalks seem more polished.
Upper West Side: Cross Central Park to the West Side, and the energy shifts completely. Here, you’re more likely to see families pushing strollers to weekend farmers’ markets and creatives lounging in Riverside Park. The streets have a more relaxed, lived-in feel, with local delis mixed among the high-end spots.
Both are undeniably “upper” Manhattan neighborhoods but show their status differently. The East Side wears its luxury like a badge of honor, while the West Side keeps things low-key and community-focused.
Quick Comparison Table
| Factor | Upper East Side | Upper West Side |
| Price Range | High (luxury real estate) | High, with more varied options |
| Community Vibe | Quiet, exclusive | Vibrant, intellectual, diverse |
| Cultural Institutions | Museums (Metropolitan Museum of Art, Guggenheim) | Music venues, theater (Lincoln Center) |
| Green Spaces | Central Park (east side) | Riverside Park, Central Park (west side) |
| Nightlife & Dining | Upscale, more sophisticated | Casual, diverse, and community-driven |
| Rental Availability | Luxury apartments, high-end buildings | Variety of rental options, more flexible choices |
What is Living on the Upper East Side Like?
Character of the Neighborhood
The Upper East Side is home to incredible traditional brownstones that look like they’re from another era (because they are), mixed with luxury high-rises. The neighborhood is known for being “old money” and super exclusive.
Everything’s clean, organized, and runs like clockwork. The streets are crazy quiet compared to the rest of Manhattan– especially once you get past Lexington Avenue heading toward Central Park. Wild for Manhattan, right?
What to Expect
You’ll spot wealthy locals walking their perfectly groomed dogs past limestone mansions and luxury co-ops. While real estate here comes at a premium, you’re paying for prime access to Museum Mile – home to the Metropolitan Museum of Art and Guggenheim, plus Central Park right at your doorstep.
The vibe is polished and traditional, with upscale restaurants and cocktail bars replacing the casual brunches you’ll find downtown. High-end designer boutiques line Fifth Avenue and Madison Avenue.
Things to Do on the Upper East Side
Start your day strolling through Central Park (East Side entrance), then see world-class art at the Met or the intimate Frick Collection. When you’re ready to splurge, hit Madison Avenue’s designer boutiques.
As night falls, grab a martini at the legendary Bemelmans Bar at the Carlyle Hotel. The hand-painted murals and live piano music will transport you to old-school New York elegance.
What is Living on the Upper West Side Like?
Character of the Neighborhood
The Upper West Side feels like the Upper East Side’s chill, brainy cousin. You’ll spot Columbia professors grabbing coffee beside young families pushing strollers and Broadway performers mixing with grad students at local wine bars.
The neighborhood strikes a sweet spot between city energy and laid-back living. It has tree-lined streets, brownstones with porches where neighbors actually chat, and plenty of indie bookstores.
While the East Side offers luxury, the West Side offers community. It has all the perks of uptown Manhattan but a more relaxed, come-as-you-are attitude.
What to Expect
On the Upper West Side, high culture meets hometown feels. You’ve got the epic Lincoln Center hosting everything from opera to ballet, plus Juilliard pumping out tomorrow’s stars. The American Museum of Natural History is your weekend go-to for dinosaurs and space shows.
Unlike the buttoned-up East Side, the West Side keeps it real with a mix of cozy cafes, family-run delis, and neighborhood bars. Grocery shopping won’t break the bank either – you’ll find Trader Joe’s, Whole Foods, and local markets with decent prices.
Things to Do on the Upper West Side
Riverside Park is your outdoor playground—a four-mile stretch perfect for biking, jogging, or watching the Hudson River sunset.
Catch world-class performances at Lincoln Center. The American Museum of Natural History is a neighborhood icon. Even if you’ve seen the dinosaurs a hundred times, there’s always a new exhibit worth checking out.
Food-wise, dig into legendary bagels and coffee at Zabar’s, grab pizza at local favorite Motorino, or treat yourself to fine dining at Jean-Georges. The cafe scene is epic, too, with spots like Irving Farm and Bluestone Lane perfect for people-watching or getting some work done.
Is the Upper East Side or Upper West Side More Expensive?
Cost Comparison
Upper East Side: Tends to have higher rent prices, particularly in luxury co-ops and condos, with a focus on high-end real estate.
- A basic 1-bedroom starts around $3,500, but prices jump fast once you get closer to Fifth or Madison Avenue
- Luxury buildings with concierges and high-end amenities typically run $5,000-6,500 for a 1-bedroom
- Co-ops and condos often require hefty down payments plus proof of significant savings
- You’ll pay premium prices at local grocery stores and restaurants
- Monthly parking can set you back $400-600
Upper West Side: Generally has a wider variety of rental options, with both high-end and more moderate prices. Rent can be slightly lower than the UES in certain areas, especially on the outskirts or in older buildings.
- Rent for a 1-bedroom apartment ranges from $3,000 to $5,500, especially north of 96th Street, with more mid-range options available.
- Luxury buildings near Lincoln Center or Central Park hit the $5,000-5,500 range
- More affordable grocery options like Trader Joe’s and local markets
- Parking runs slightly cheaper, around $350-500 monthly
Subsection: Affordability in Both Neighborhoods
UES is known for its luxury listings, but prices start dropping if you walk east of Third Avenue. UWS offers more variety. Young professionals and students often have better luck here, especially in older buildings between Broadway and Amsterdam Avenue and smaller apartments.
Rental Game: What You Need to Know
Competition for Apartments
The rental market in these hottest NYC neighborhoods can be competitive. UES has a more concentrated market for luxury listings, meaning higher competition for premium apartments. Plus, the boards can be strict if you’re looking at a co-op.
UWS has more rental variety, making finding a place that fits your budget and lifestyle easier. Short-term lease? Sure. Need a quick sublet in a private room? You can find those, too, especially in buildings catering to students or young professionals.
Typical Lease Terms
The standard lease term in both neighborhoods is 12 months, but flexibility (such as shorter-term leases) is more common in the UWS.
Upper East Side apartments tend to be in luxury buildings with more rigid lease terms. And if you’re dealing with a co-op board, expect a strict approval process.
Broker Fees and Rent-Controlled Apartments
In Upper East Side vs Upper West Side, UES often has higher broker fees. Rent-controlled apartments are rarer in this area.
UWS may offer older rental buildings with rent-controlled or rent-stabilized apartments. These gems tend to be on the side streets, especially as you head uptown past 86th Street, in neighborhoods farther from Riverside Park. Broker fees can be more reasonable here, with some buildings offering no-fee rentals.
Public Transportation and Commuting: UES vs. UWS
Upper East Side
In Upper East Side vs Upper West Side, UES has limited subway options. The 6 line runs along Lexington Avenue, and the Q line along Second Avenue. The Q line helps, especially if you live on the far east side. But it only runs up to 96th Street, so if you’re above that, you’re stuck with the 6 train.
Cross-town travel can be slow due to fewer east-west routes, so commuting may take longer during rush hour. Many people use ride-shares or biking because the subway options are limited—just something to consider when planning your commute budget.
Upper West Side
The UWS benefits from better subway access, with the 1, 2, 3, B, and C lines serving the area. The 1, 2, and 3 trains run along Broadway, while the B and C lines go down Central Park West. Plus, most stations have local and express trains, so you can switch it up depending on where you’re headed.
Example of Commute Times: Upper East Side vs Upper West Side
From UES 68th St-Hunter College station to:
- Midtown: 20 minutes (6 line).
- Times Square: 20-25 minutes (take the 6 to Grand Central, then switch to the S shuttle or walk)
- Grand Central: 15 minutes direct on the 6 train
- Wall Street: 30-35 minutes on the 6 train
- Union Square: 15-20 minutes on the 6 train
From UWS 72nd St station, you can get to:
- Midtown/Times Square: 15 minutes on the 1 train
- Penn Station: 12 minutes on the 2/3 express
- Union Square: 20 minutes on the 1 train
- Financial District: 25-30 minutes on the 2/3 express
Nightlife, Dining, and Lifestyle: UES vs. UWS
Upper East Side
The nightlife here is more suit-and-tie than jeans-and-sneakers, with high-end bars, cocktail lounges, and private clubs. Popular spots include Bemelmans Bar and the bars at the Carlyle Hotel. Picture perfect martinis, live jazz, and walls painted with whimsical murals.
The dining scene is high-end, with gourmet restaurants and luxury dining experiences. For example, Daniel is the kind of place you save for special occasions, and Café Boulud is its slightly more casual cousin but still a “make a reservation” kind of spot.
Upper West Side
Nightlife in the Upper West Side is more relaxed and accessible, with a mix of live music venues, casual bars, and community hangouts. Popular spots include The Beacon Theatre, which hosts big-name concerts and comedy shows, and Jazz at Lincoln Center.
The dining scene is more diverse—options range from affordable cafes to trendy restaurants. The Smith is always packed because it works for everything – date night, brunch with friends, or dinner with your parents.
Lifestyle
- UES: Quiet, residential living, with luxury amenities and a prestigious social atmosphere. You can actually hear birds in the morning instead of traffic, and people take their routines seriously.
- UWS: Active and vibrant, perfect for those who enjoy a strong community feel and cultural engagement.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Is the Upper East Side or Upper West Side Better?
Neither is “better”—it depends on your lifestyle preferences.
Is the Upper West Side a Rich Area?
Yes, but it’s not just rich people. You’ll find everyone from Columbia students to young families to longtime residents in rent-stabilized apartments.
What Celebrities Live on the Upper East Side?
Some notable residents include John F. Kennedy Jr., Sarah Jessica Parker, and Beyoncé.
Is the Upper East Side Old Money?
Yes. The UES is often associated with old money, generational wealth, and prestigious families like the Rockefellers.
Is the Upper West Side Safe to Live In?
Yes. The UWS is considered very safe with an active, involved community.
Conclusion: Which Neighborhood is Right for You?
The Upper East Side is known for old-money glamor with higher price tags on everything from rent to restaurant tabs. The streets are quieter, the buildings more prestigious, and the vibe is more buttoned-up.
Meanwhile, the Upper West Side is equally high-end but has a more laid-back, intellectual feel. You’ll find housing options at various price points, better grocery store options, a diverse mix of residents, and a community atmosphere.
Final recommendation
- UES: Ideal for those seeking luxury, exclusivity, and proximity to high-end shopping and culture.
- UWS: Perfect for young professionals, students, and families looking for a more relaxed and community-focused environment with easy access to nature, culture, and a diverse dining scene.
Either way, you’re getting prime Manhattan living—just with a different flavor.
Explore More About New York City
- Upper East Side vs. Upper West Side: Which is Right For You?
- Every Manhattan Neighborhood, Explained Like a Local
- The Most Expensive & Richest Neighborhoods in NYC
- What Are the Safest Neighborhoods in Manhattan?
- 9 Best Neighborhoods in Queens to Live
- New York City’s Safest Neighborhoods and Places to Live
